STONE CRAB SEASON STARTS IN
A key lime pie with a graham cracker crust on a wooden board, with a slice being served using a silver pie server. Two lime wedges are also present on the board.

Fireman Derek's Key Lime Pie – Captain Stone Crab

$49.99
$49.99
$35.00
Sold Out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
SKU Key Lime Pie

Fireman Derek's award-winning Key Lime Pie! 🥧 🍴

If you’re going to order a slice of the Florida Keys, no meal would be complete without an authentic, award-winning Key Lime Pie. Provided by our friends at Fireman Derek’s bake shop, this sweet and tart classic pie was voted “Miami’s Best Key Lime Pie'' by the Miami New Times. This pie features a graham cracker crust and hand-squeezed key limes. So good.

Overall rating: 4.5 / 5 from 10 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Summary topics

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

Reviews

What a disappointment!

"Pie was crushed. Plastic seemed to be melted to the pie. Under the pie was sticky. Not what I expected, considering what I paid for this."

— Michael I. (1/5)

I was born in Miami

"I was born in Miami Florida in 1957 lived on SW 191 st and 124 ave our home my mother made sure had a big true key lime tree and of course a avocado tree So I was always had real key lime’s fresh from the tree and loved them on my avocado and I always love a true real key lime pie Thanks you"

— Warne M. (5/5)

Perfect Key Lime Pie

"Excellent pie!! Would definitely order again!!!"

— Carole W. (5/5)

Stoned

"Claws were good, Pie was good"

— John B. (4/5)

Well packaged.Quickly delivered.

"Well packaged.Quickly delivered."

— A B. (5/5)

I gave it to my

"I gave it to my office manager family they loved all of it"

— Douglas N. (5/5)

Excellent

"Excellent"

— Grigoriy K. (5/5)

👍

"👍"

— Lynsey J. (5/5)

Great pie!

"Easily one of the best Key Lime pies I’ve had!"

— Chad B. (5/5)

The Key lime pie and

"The Key lime pie and the Stone Crabs were Delicious!!! 😀😀"

— Elaine M. (5/5)

Q&A